AEMC shirks its duty to ensure safety of accelerated smart meter rollout

The Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) made a draft rule in April that would accelerate the deployment of smart meters in much of Australia.

Stakeholders were encouraged to ‘help shape the solution’ by lodging submissions on the draft rule by 30 May 2024. The AEMC claimed that this would contribute to well-informed, high quality rule changes.

Sadly, this does not appear to be the case. 

More than two thirds of the submissions did NOT support an accelerated roll out of smart meters.

Over 100 submissions voiced objections and raised serious safety issues in regard to health and privacy.

Yet, despite this clearly articulated opposition, the AEMC’s Directions paper of 15 August stated that ‘Stakeholders agree that there are benefits from an accelerated rollout, including most importantly benefits to customers from having earlier access to smart meter technology’, citing submissions to the draft determination as being the source for this surprising claim.

As the majority of the submissions objecting to an accelerated roll out of smart meters came from individuals (in other words, the actual stakeholders who will suffer the consequences of the proposed acceleration), does this mean that, yet again, it’s the spin of big business that dwarfs common sense?

Implementation of the Accelerating Smart Meter Deployment draft rule has now been pushed out from the original date slated for early July to 28 November 2024.

This provides a small reprieve for Australians.  But for those of us who place safety above profits, it gives cold comfort in the light of the AEMC’s refusal to genuinely engage with members of the community.

The AEMC has not, to-date, made an attempt to publicly address safety concerns that were raised in submissions.  Instead, it has elected to only focus on retail tariff issues. Submissions for these were due on 12 September.  

Is this a case of the AEMC fiddling whilst Rome burns?

Information on the draft Accelerating Smart Meter Deployment rule change is available at the following link: https://www.aemc.gov.au/rule-changes/accelerating-smart-meter-deployment

Submissions to the April draft rule determination can be accessed by clicking on ‘Draft’ in the ‘Select an option’ box (under Documentation).

Stop Smart Meters Australia’s submission to the April draft rule determination is available here.

SSMA’s previous post on the draft Accelerating Smart Meter Deployment rule can be viewed here.

Posted in Smart Meter | Tagged , , , , , | 7 Comments

Victorian South East Water customers, beware…..

TPG lands South East Water smart meter contract for Victoria

The nation’s third-largest telco has outmanoeuvred its biggest competitor to land the largest smart meter rollout in Australia, over a stretch that’s tens of thousands of kilometres long.

TPG has nabbed the 10-year Victorian deal from South East Water, part of a major smart upgrade of its water meters that will remove the need for meter readers altogether.

Both TPG and Telstra had provided connectivity for the 90,000 smart meters already operated but it was the underdog that landed the ultimate contract and will connect and manage one million meters to be rolled out over the next decade.

It’s a relatively new area for the telco but one it hopes to take ownership of, said Chris Russo, TPG’s general manager enterprise and government customer sales and solutions 

“It’s the start of a very big ambition of ours which is to take category leadership in water metering support from a connectivity perspective, and to really own that domain from a telco capability,” she said.

Ms Russo said TPG viewed the deal as exciting as it was a chance to be a part of the water industry’s digital transformation as well as test the limits of its ­network.

“The market is nascent in its level of digital adoption,” she said. “We can see it’s an industry that is rife with innovation and it’s got a lot of digital adoption to do and that’s exciting for us because we can play a part and in doing so we can really demonstrate the robust nature of our network.”

Each water meter will be ­fitted with a 4G sim and TPG will provide connectivity and the ­analytics platform that South East Water will use.

The telco will also batch test a certain number of meters for quality and assurance testing.

A digital water meter is priced between $150 and $200 depending on the type of sensors it has inside and depending on which of the three suppliers South East Water uses it comes from.

Mark Elvins, SEW’s acting general manager of digital utility, said work had already begun to replace meters across Victoria.

Each meter takes about 10 minutes to replace and can connect to the network within minutes, with its first report provided within 24 hours. From there, customers would be able to get a daily update of their water use that can be broken down into 30-minute increments.

SEW had about 42 installers who would work to replace between 800 and 900 a day, with a goal of up to 200,000 per year……..

Abridged from: The Australian

Posted in Smart Meter | 3 Comments

Get ready for the spin on smart meters

Letter to the Editor – Canberra CityNews:

I’ve just made a submission on smart meters to the Australian Energy
Market Commission (AEMC). 

AEMCis currently looking at accelerating smart meter deployment in NSW, Queensland, the ACT and SA, following a request from industry players Intellihub, SA Power Networks and Alinta Energy. 

Smart meters are promoted by industry and regulators as the best thing since sliced bread. However, the replacement of electromechanical meters with digital technology has resulted in locking consumers into a continuing cycle of higher electricity bills. 

Accumulation meters have a long lifespan, whereas smart meters need to be replaced over time. Smart meters also depend on sophisticated technology, requiring communication networks, data storage, software applications and technical expertise.

Research released by The Australia Institute in 2019 showed that “time of use pricing” facilitated by smart meters drives up household energy costs. Electricity companies and regulators push for higher electricity prices at peak times, as well as higher “shoulder” periods. In theory, this encourages people to move their energy consumption to times of the day when it is cheaper for utilities to provide it.

The Australia Institute concluded that many households have now exhausted their capacity to cut electricity consumption or change their time of electricity use. In reality, electricity companies are using electricity demand peaks to push for higher consumer prices to increase their profits.

The call to accelerate the smart meter rollout is clearly about industry interests over that of consumers. Get ready for more spin saying it’s all about the advantages for consumers. Guess who is paying?

Murray May, Cook

Source: CBRCityNews

Information of the Australia Institute 2019 research can be found here

Posted in Smart Meter | 6 Comments

Smart Meters, Dirty Electricity, Pulses and Health – New Resource

Health complaints from smart meters installed by the thousands in homes are no longer surprising.

A free resource has recently been updated and translated into English that aims to provide an overview of smart meters, with a focus on health effects. This resource is for anyone who is interested in learning more about smart meters. It is well referenced and can be used by anyone.

To download the book, go to: https://einarflydal.com/sdm_downloads/download-smartmeters-dirty-electricity-pulses-and-health-pdf/

Posted in Smart Meter | 1 Comment

AEMC moves to accelerate the roll out of smart meters in Australia

The Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) has made a draft rule designed to turbocharge the deployment of smart meters. The draft rule determination states that the rule would achieve ‘universal uptake of smart meters in the NEM [National Energy Market] by 2030’.

The new rule represents a major departure from the ‘Expanding competition in metering and related services’ electricity rule that came into force in Tasmania, New South Wales, South Australia, Queensland and the Australian Capital Territory on 1 December 2017. 

Customers would no longer be given the option to retain legacy meters when retailers are undertaking meter replacements. 

Retailers would be required to use their best endeavours to meet yearly interim targets.  New civil penalties would apply to retailers for non-compliance with the final 2030 target of universal smart meter penetration. 

The new draft rule, however, does not remove the right for customers to elect to have a non-communicating (Type 4A) smart meter.  The AEMC’s 2023 report, titled Review of the regulatory framework for metering services, stated that currently less than 0.01 per cent of customers had opted for Type 4A meters. 

In practice, the new Accelerating Smart Meter Deployment rule would affect customers in NSW, SA, QLD and the ACT.  The AEMC said that Tasmania already has an acceleration program in place. 

The number of notices that retailers would be required to send to customers before a meter deployment has been reduced from two to one.  The minimum notice period would also be shortened.  The notice would be required to be given to the customer no earlier than 60 business days and no later than 4 business days before the retailer proposes to replace the meter.  Currently, the minimum period required to give notice to a customer about an impending meter replacement is 15 business days. 

The AEMC can only make and amend the electricity and energy retail rules if doing so will contribute to the relevant energy objective. This takes into account the long term interests of customers with respect to price, quality, safety, reliability and security of electricity as well as targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

For further information on the draft rule and to make a submission, go to: https://www.aemc.gov.au/rule-changes/accelerating-smart-meter-deployment

Submissions close on 30 May 2024. 

The AEMC’s tips for making a submission can be accessed at the following link: https://www.aemc.gov.au/our-work/changing-energy-rules-unique-process/making-rule-change-request/submission-tips

Posted in Smart Meter | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Victorian petition to allow disabling of remote function of electricity smart meters

Current regulations in Victoria do not allow for the disabling of the remote function of electricity smart meters. The fact remains that Victorians are subjected to among the harshest smart meter policies in Australia.  Elsewhere, customers have the right to refuse a meter with wireless communications.  In other Australian jurisdictions, even if a smart meter has already been installed, customers are entitled to have their meter’s pulsed microwave transmissions disabled.

This needs to change! In view of this appalling state of affairs, SSMA urges Victorian residents to sign an e-petition addressed to the Victorian Legislative Council (Upper House) calling on the government to change regulations in Victoria to allow for the disabling of the remote function of electricity smart meters.

TO VIEW AND SIGN THE PETITION, GO TO:

https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/get-involved/petitions/allow-disabling-of-remote-function-of-electricity-smart-meters

The Australian Radiation Protection and Nuclear Safety Agency (ARPANSA) advise, “There have been anecdotal reports into potential health effects of exposure to RF EME [radio frequency electromagnetic energy] from smart meters claiming of a variety of ill effects that have been generally termed ‘electromagnetic hypersensitivity’ or EHS.” The current options to assist customers, offered by distributors United Energy and Powercor, do not address health concerns as they do not allow for the removal of this direct source of RF EME from properties.

Posted in Smart Meter | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 17 Comments

Is Your Body Overwhelmed By This”Electro-Pollution”?

Smart meters, Smart phones, Bluetooth, Mobile phone towers, Wi-Fi….

Scientists and medical doctors reveal the shocking truth about electro-sensitivity: fatigue, insomnia, headaches, tinnitus and much more… and share how you can minimise your exposure and recover from this constant zapping.

You are invited to attend a FREE online EMF Hazards Summit, 11 – 14 April 2024.

To view EMF Hazards Summit video trailer and to register go to: https://emfhazards.com/

Posted in Smart Meter | 3 Comments

Remembering Nearfield – Award winning short film

One Woman. One Disability. One Powerful Voice for change. Remembering Nearfield is an animated film about a disability called electrohypersensitivity (EHS).

Because of severe Electromagnetic Hypersensitivity, Wi-Fi is the last thing she needs, along with the social discrimination against her disability. She wants solutions, not excuses. Her life matters.

Remembering Nearfield

Posted in Smart Meter | 2 Comments

French court orders removal of man’s smart meter

He had been suffering from headaches which he claims were due to electro-sensitivity triggered by the Linky [smart] meter

27 December 2023

Linky smart meter   Pic: pixinoo / Shutterstock

By Richard Henshell

A man who claimed to be suffering from headaches due to his Linky meter has won a court battle to have it removed.

Joseph Cascina from Saint-André-le-Puy (Loire) reported hearing a “constant whistling” in his head after its installation.

“All day, all night… Every evening I had to take a pill to get to sleep, life had become hell,” he told France 3.

“When I left my home, the whistling stopped within an hour. And at my in-laws’ house, where there is no Linky meter, I didn’t hear it either. But when I got back home, within a quarter of an hour, the sound started again.”

Mr Cascina, who had reported no symptoms prior to the Linky meter’s installation, asked Enedis to remove it. When the company refused, he took them to court in January 2023.

The court in Saint-Etienne noted that Mr Cascina was suffering, and ruled that the meter should be removed.

The ruling was based on the court’s interpretation of the European Court of Justice’s ‘Principle of precaution’. 

This states that “in case of doubt as to the cause or extent of harm to individuals, institutions can require protective measures without waiting for the reality of the risks to be fully established.”

Enedis replaced Mr Cascina’s Linky meter with an older model, but appealed, aware that many opponents to Linky meters could act upon the decision.

However, on November 28 the Court of Appeal in Lyon upheld the original ruling.

The court’s decision was celebrated by the Stop Linky 5G collective, which opposes the mandatory installation of Linky meters.

“The three judges ruled that the court was faced with symptoms that are justifiable,” said spokesperson Denis Nicolier. “Enedis, which has a public service mission, must protect users in the context of the Principle of precaution.”

Linky meters, which were first introduced in 2018, have been fitted in more than 90% of households. People who do not want one in their home must pay a surcharge, however the ruling on health grounds makes Mr Cascina exempt from this.

What is electromagnetic hypersensitivity?

Electromagnetic hypersensitivity (EHS) was recognised as a handicap in France in 2015. 

“The symptoms are varied: headaches, chronic fatigue, rashes, concentration problems and more,” Professor Luc Fontana of the University Hospital of Saint-Étienne told France 3.

“The challenge is in ascribing these symptoms to the syndrome, since initially, one must be careful to check they are not due to another health problem.”

In a 2005 report, the World Health Organisation said that the symptoms are “certainly real”, but added that “there is no scientific basis to link EHS symptoms to electromagnetic field exposure.”

An estimated 5% of the population, or 3.5 million people in France could be affected by the syndrome, according to a 2018 report by France’s National Social Security Administration, ANSES.

Many such people are already members of groups that oppose Linky meters in France, including the Stop Linky 5G collective, which hopes that the court’s decision will help spread awareness about the condition.

“The real value here is that doctors and judges worked together to study a typical case of electromagnetic hypersensitivity and look for answers,” Mr Nicolier said.

Source: The Connexion

Posted in Smart Meter | Tagged , , , , , , | 5 Comments

Doctors, Lawyers, and Scientists Join Together in International Children’s Declaration for the Digital Age

NEW YORK, Nov. 1, 2023 /PRNewswire/ — An international group of leading lawyers, physicians, physicists, epidemiologists and other children’s health experts have today announced their support for a new International Declaration intended to raise public awareness of three fundamental rights of children which are not adequately being protected: the right to be free from addictive platforms and apps; the right to be free from hazardous radiation from wireless devices; and the right to be free from commercial exploitation of private information.

Children have a fundamental human right to be free from addiction, exposure and exploitation in the digital world.

Children around the world are suffering from digital addiction, radiation exposure and commercial exploitation.
Children around the world are suffering from digital addiction, radiation exposure and commercial exploitation.

The “International Declaration on the Human Rights of Children in the Digital Age,” builds on the 1959 United Nations Declaration on the Rights of the Child and encourage decision makers at all levels of government and education to take immediate steps to safeguard children from potential harm. The Declaration is being promoted by two non-profit organizations, the Broadband International Legal Action Network of California (BBILAN), and Americans for Responsible Technology based in New York.

The Declaration will be presented to the United Nations on World Children’s Day,  20th November.

Abridged from press release.

In addition to the legal, health, scientific experts and child advocates who have signed, signatures from the general public are essential to show strong support. So please EVERYONE sign and share widely! 

To sign – https://www.thechildrensdeclaration.org/become-a-signatory

Declaration text – https://www.thechildrensdeclaration.org/the-declaration 

Posted in Electromagnetic radiation, EMF, EMR | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment