Power distributors advocate optional smart meters in Victoria – But will the Victorian Labor Government listen?

Last year the Victorian Government, through the Department of Environment, Land, Water and Planning (DELWP), issued an Options Paper asking for feedback on proposed changes to the way electricity metering is installed and managed in Victoria. The purpose of the paper was to give Victorian community and industry stakeholders the opportunity to provide their views on how Victoria can best transition to the new national arrangements for metering competition for households and small businesses.

What is of particular interest to Stop Smart Meters Australia is the question posed by DELWP on whether Victoria should vary its current policy position on the ‘mandatory’ nature of smart meters, in order to fall in line with national arrangements.  (See our post entitled Smart Meters by Stealth for an overview of consumers’ right to opt out under the new national rule commencing 1 December 2017.)

The 18 responses to DELWP make for some very interesting reading:

In response to whether Victoria should vary its current policy position that smart meters are mandatory and allow households and small businesses to opt out of having a communicating smart meter Jemena wrote:

“About 2 % of JEN’s customers have steadfastly refused a communicating AMI smart meter. We consider customers should be able to opt out of having a communicating smart meter. The opt-out policy would be consistent with the national metering competition framework and reflects the customers’ interests.” (Emphasis added).

AusNet Services wrote:

“The current CROIC [Cost Recovery Order in Council] allows Victorian customers to refuse a smart meter exchange leaving the old meter in place. Whilst the national smart meter framework requires customers to receive a manually read interval meter instead. This essentially promotes the practice of removing communications modules from functioning meters, although we currently offer in very limited circumstances such as hypersensitivity. We would not support removing the communications module for any other reason.” (Emphasis added)

This is great news; both Jemena and AusNet services argue that smart meters should not be compulsory in Victoria, and AusNet Services acknowledges some people do suffer from electrohypersensitivity (EHS) as a result of the pulsed radiation emitted by smart meters. Yet the Andrews Labor Government REFUSES to admit this!!

Red Energy and Lumo Energy wrote:

“Red and Lumo support the national arrangements applying in Victoria, inclusive of the ability for customers to choose not to have a communicating smart meter.” (Emphasis added)

Yet United Energy disagrees, writing that smart meters should always be installed except on “the few occasions when telecommunications network and signal strength cannot are not available at the metering installation.” (Emphasis added)

This is typical of this heartless company who even refused to exchange their smart meter for a disabled young lady who suffered excruciating pain as a result of the pulsed radiation emitted from her smart meter. This woman’s mother wrote:

“United Energy have no empathy at all. They do not give a damn who suffers, and they will continue to deny that the smart meter is a health risk for some people. They continue to lie. I feel so very angry and frustrated that this is actually happening and that no one, including politicians and journalists, are brave enough to do anything about this.” See: https://stopsmartmeters.com.au/2014/05/15/nicolas-nightmare-continues/



And to top it off, the so-called Joint Consumer Groups’ submission advocates for the maintenance of mandatory smart meters. They wrote:

“Many of the identified benefits flowing from smart meters rely on communications technology. Customers opting out of having a communicating smart meter on any significant scale would diminish the value of processes currently undertaken by network businesses, including network management, safety and remote energisation. Given the benefits that flow from a fully communicating network, and that this requirement is already in place, there is little rationale for a change in approach at this stage. There have been a number of changes to this policy over the period of the rollout. To realise the societal benefits the policy should remain that advanced meters remain mandatory for households and small business.” (Emphasis added)

It is a simple and well known fact, that smart meters overwhelmingly benefit the multinational companies who install them and NOT consumers. See for example:





The partners of the Joint Consumer Groups’ submission are: The Alternative Technology Association (ATA), Consumer Action Law Centre (Consumer Action), Consumer Utilities Advocacy Centre (CUAC), the Brotherhood of St Laurence, Community Information & Support Victoria and St Vincent de Paul Society.

These organisations should be ashamed of themselves for abandoning the very people they claim to support.

This entry was posted in Smart Meter and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Power distributors advocate optional smart meters in Victoria – But will the Victorian Labor Government listen?

  1. Pingback: Smart Meters Agenda 20 30 | Protect Australia Now

  2. Maria says:

    Well I have written about the smart meter ,over a yr ago to the local Labour MP of Cranbourne .,who used to send leaflets to write to him for any issues., and the response he gave me was that it is compulsory to put the smart meter and it’s the law of the state .,something to that effect..
    Hence there was no support at all.
    ive written to him as I was being hassled by post by the distributor about not allowing the smart meter etc to be placed in home and it was v intimidating..
    And I even asked the GP to write a note TO distributor .,as if u had a medical note they stop hassling u .,but the dr refused…
    .I find even wth mobile phone or iPad I cannot work on them long as I get side effects …

  3. Daryl Bradforde says:

    Any new meter installed in NSW from July 2017 will be a smart meter.

    See the following article

    “To date smart meters have been rolled out on a voluntary basis in NSW, after a mandatory mass roll-out in Victoria was widely criticised. But from July this year, any new meters installed in NSW homes MUST be a smart meter.”

    The new rules for Competition in Metering Services commence 01 DEC 2017 where customers can choose to have the communication card removed from installed smart meters.

    Beware anybody in NSW who is having a meter installed from July 2017. Unless you object it is most likely that you will have a smart meter installed with it’s communication card wirelessly transmitting radiation through your home. It’s time to lock up boxes in NSW before July 2017.

  4. Happy Dissenter says:

    Keep up the resistance my friends. Loving seeing the actual figures for households who refuse to submit to these dumb expensive health-sapping devices. Be strong.

  5. Anonymous says:

    my family for one is senstive to smart meters. our additional problem is we fitted solar panels before we knew what we were letting ourselves in for…………we elected to keep the analogue because we knew one of us was hypersentive but have since then had a fight with Energy Australia over wrong …overcharging. historically prior to fitting solar panels we averaged 8.6kwh usage over the previous 2 or so years and Energy Australia want to charge us about 10khw day…go figure…….and we are producing about 7.5khw per day average power from the solar panels. and I am keeping pretty much daily figures inverter and analogue reading. but that I guess is another issue. I for one would like to see smart meters optional with the communicating device removed and also aerial. only then will I consider a digital meter.

  6. fiona says:

    I just about fell off my chair when I read about AusNet accepting hypersensitivity. I experienced excruciating pain from the V8 smart meter for 2 years. So debilitated unable to move until someone was able to help me shift. I wrote many letters and had phone calls and received no compassion and no understanding. It has now been 5 years and I have not fully recovered from this assault though spend time and money daily on this. It is now chronic.The body went into a state of PTSD from my experience – the constant electrical shocks and burning, the denials, sense of being trapped and unable to move somewhere safe, no support, no one listening etc etc.
    Great that they can say this now. Maybe it will help someone. In the meant time how much karma they have created for themselves by knowingly assaulting so many people. How many people have their ignorance affected? Will they pay compensation? Will they say sorry?

    • Dear Fiona – I realize it’s been a long time since you wrote that missive above – but would like to get in touch with another soul who has and is suffering the same symptoms as I am…. please drop me a line here in the comments and if its ok – send your email address,,Kathy

Leave a comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s